Tomlinson OW; Barker AR; Fulford J; Wilson P; Shelley J; Oades PJ; Williams CA

Frontiers in pediatrics [Front Pediatr] 2023 Jun 14; Vol. 11, pp. 1211547.
Date of Electronic Publication: 2023 Jun 14 (Print Publication: 2023).

Background: Increased maximal oxygen uptake (V̇O _2max ) is beneficial in children with cystic fibrosis (CF) but remains lower compared to healthy peers. Intrinsic metabolic deficiencies within skeletal muscle (muscle “quality”) and skeletal muscle size (muscle “quantity”) are both proposed as potential causes for the lower V̇O _2max , although exact mechanisms remain unknown. This study utilises gold-standard methodologies to control for the residual effects of muscle size from V̇O _2max to address this “quality” vs. “quantity” debate.
Methods: Fourteen children (7 CF vs. 7 age- and sex-matched controls) were recruited. Parameters of muscle size – muscle cross-sectional area (mCSA) and thigh muscle volume (TMV) were derived from magnetic resonance imaging, and V̇O _2max obtained via cardiopulmonary exercise testing. Allometric scaling removed residual effects of muscle size, and independent samples t -tests and effect sizes (ES) identified differences between groups in V̇O _2max , once mCSA and TMV were controlled for.
Results: V̇O _2max was shown to be lower in the CF group, relative to controls, with large ES being identified when allometrically scaled to mCSA (ES = 1.76) and TMV (ES = 0.92). Reduced peak work rate was also identified in the CF group when allometrically controlled for mCSA (ES = 1.18) and TMV (ES = 0.45).
Conclusions: A lower V̇O _2max was still observed in children with CF after allometrically scaling for muscle size, suggesting reduced muscle “quality” in CF (as muscle “quantity” is fully controlled for). This observation likely reflects intrinsic metabolic defects within CF skeletal muscle.